Kaufman's Response to Lucretius

TitleKaufman's Response to Lucretius
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2008
AuthorsJohansson, J
JournalPacific Philosophical Quarterly
Volume89
Pagination470-485
Abstract

Abstract:  The symmetry argument is an objection to the 'deprivation approach'– the account of badness favored by nearly all philosophers who take death to be bad for the one who dies. Frederik Kaufman's recent response to the symmetry argument is a development of Thomas Nagel's suggestion that we could not have come into existence substantially earlier than we in fact did. In this paper, I aim to show that Kaufman's suggestion fails. I also consider several possible modifications of his theory, and argue that they are unsuccessful as well.