Justifying Punishment: A Response to Douglas Husak

TitleJustifying Punishment: A Response to Douglas Husak
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2008
AuthorsBrownlee, K
JournalCriminal Law and Philosophy
Volume2
Pagination123-129
Abstract

In â€{}Why Criminal Law: A Question of Content?â€, Douglas Husak argues that an analysis of the justifiability of the criminal law depends upon an analysis of the justifiability of state punishment. According to Husak, an adequate justification of state punishment both must show why the state is permitted to infringe valuable rights such as the right not to be punished and must respond to two distinct groups of persons who may demand a justification for the imposition of punishment, namely, individuals subjected to punishment and the society asked to support the institution of punishment. In this discussion, I analyse Husakâ€{}s account of the right not to be punished with an eye to showing that the parameters of that right do not extend to the cases that would make it controversial. I also consider two other distinct groups of persons who have equal standing to alleged offenders and society to demand justification for the imposition of state punishment, namely, direct victims of crimes and criminal justice officials